Targeting Innovation

If government is going to get more involved with the economy — OK, OK, since government is going to get more involved with the economy — the new administration should take a look at the plan proposed by Bill George (former Medtronic CEO and now a professor of management practice at Harvard) published at Business Week.  George asserts that his plan “will jump-start the innovation economy by providing built-in long-term growth, redistributing wealth without punishing the wealthy, and creating millions of well-paying jobs.”

Managing Cash Effectively with Pools of Funds

My column for the Tennessean this week is the third in a series on managing cash flow:

My previous two columns have examined why the phrase “cash is king” is so true and what steps entrepreneurs can take to improve their cash flow.

So what is the purpose of building up cash reserves? Think of your cash reserves as four pools of funding with four distinct purposes.

The first pool of cash is to plan for those large expenses that are not part of regular monthly expenses, but are critical nonetheless. Examples are quarterly tax payments, annual equipment replacement purchases, or large seasonal marketing campaigns.

Create a calendar of these payments and put cash aside to build up enough to cover them.

The second pool of cash is used to better manage the natural “lumpiness” of cash flow. The reality is that the rate that cash flows into a business is never smooth and predictable. Some businesses have to pay for products to be made or for services to be provided well before they actually get paid. Other businesses may have seasonal sales swings, such as many retail businesses that have most of their sales in November and December.

This second pool of cash should be used to create your own internal line of credit to help navigate the natural “lumpiness” of cash flow.

Be ready for the unexpected

Think of the third pool of cash as your emergency fund. This pool should be large enough to cover at least a month of day-to-day expenses. This will help cushion you from events such as an unexpected loss of a major customer or a major disruption of your business.

I remember one year in our health-care company when we lost about two weeks of sales in the aftermath of a hurricane in September, followed by the loss of about 10 days of sales due to a major ice storm in January. Cash reserves are what got us through those tough times.

The final pool of cash is for an “opportunity war chest.”

Recessions create many opportunities for financially strong companies. There may be opportunities to acquire a competitor’s business that’s been weakened by the economy or to expand and fill the void left by a competitor’s failure.

It may actually prove to be a good time to expand the business — real estate prices, the cost to rent space, equipment expenses and labor costs will all be lower.

Develop an annual plan to forecast all of the needs for a cash reserve.

Create a separate bank account to keep these funds segregated from the cash needed for day-to-day operations.

And make regular and frequent transfers into this account whenever possible to ensure that the funds will be available when you need them.

A Prayer for the New Year

I offered the invocation for the hooding ceremony of our graduating MBA students last evening.  Let me offer it to all entrepreneurs as a prayer for the new year:

 

Lord, we thank you for these entrepreneurs and business leaders. 

 

We pray that they understand that their work on earth should never be just a career, but a true vocation that connects their faith to all they do in the work.  We pray that they remember that true integrity is to find God helping us to live as He intended us to live in all that we do:  in our family, in our community, and in our work.

 

We pray that they always remember that real Courage is the courage to the right thing even under the most difficult circumstances.  It is the courage to treat all people justly, even in difficult economic times like these.

 

We pray that they never forget that all they are given in this life comes from God, so they should be prudent stewards of all of His gifts. 

 

We pray that they temper their drive to succeed in their careers – keeping time for their spouses, their children, their families, their friends, their community, and of course, for God.

 

We pray that while they may attain great power in their careers, that they remain humble.  We pray that no matter how successful they become that they always see the face of Jesus in everyone they meet in their work.

 

Finally, we pray that we never lose faith, even in difficult times like these.  Jesus said, “I am leaving you with a gift–peace of mind and heart. And the peace I give is a gift the world cannot give. So don’t be troubled or afraid.” 

 

We pray that we never forget that God gives us peace, even in the worst of times.

 

All of this we pray in the name of your Son, Jesus Christ.

 

Amen.

Follow-up on Community Banks Outlook for 2009

In a follow-up to the post I wrote yesterday, the Nashville Post has a story today that confirms my outlook for bank lending to entrepreneurial ventures in 2009.

From Geert De Lombaerde’s story:

The credit crisis taking its toll on parts of Nashville’s banking sector could be setting the stage for a clear 2009 division of the haves and the have-nots.

A NashvillePost.com analysis of Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. third-quarter filings shows that four of the top nine banks based in Middle Tennessee or doing most of their business here trimmed their loan portfolios from July to September.  

Such is the case with community banks all across the country, although in some markets small business lending has come to a complete stop.

Geert used my analysis from yesterday as support for his assessment that this “tight lending environment will be with us for a while.” 

However, the surveys of business owners are all beginning to tell us the same story — most entrepreneurs are not really looking for new credit right now, anyway. 

Financing Outlook for 2009

So what will be the watchwords for financing entrepreneurial ventures in 2009? 

  • Bootstrapping 
  • Angel investments.

I have had some interesting conversations with several small business friendly bankers over the past couple of weeks.  They are telling me that with the tight margins created by the interest rate cuts, they will be very stingy with new lending for entrepreneurial deals during the foreseeable future.  And that was before the recent cut by the Fed.

Family and friends will be tight on investing in new deals as their investment portfolios have tanked.  They no longer feel wealthy, so will not be as interested in altruistic investments into high risk start-ups.

VCs are reeling right now.  From Techcrunch:

The number of partners listed on some VC Websites is already quietly shrinking. Some new VC funds are having difficulty raising money and even existing funds are running into problems collecting commitments from strapped limited partners.

The carnage on Wall Street is having a trickle-down effect on venture capital firms. The limited partners who typically invest in VC funds–university endowments, pension funds, investment banks, other institutions, and wealthy individuals–are short of cash right now. Harvard’s endowment lost $8 billion in the past four months alone. Many limited partners simply cannot honor capital calls from VCs.  (When a VC firm creates a new fund, it does not collect all the money at once. Instead, it receives promises from limited partners that they will invest when the capital is needed). 

Angel investors seem to be in a little better shape.  Those who work with angels tell me that deals are still being funding.  They see opportunity in the current market for significant long term returns.  They tend to have a longer time horizon than VC firms and have only themselves to be accountable to for the deals they fund.  This backs up a recent report from Angel Capital Association which stated:

Angel group leaders report in a recent survey by the Angel Capital Association (ACA) that investments have decreased this year and will decline as well in 2009 compared to 2007 due to the current recession. However, some angel groups have increased their investment activity this year and believe they will make additional investments in 2009 as new opportunities arise from difficult economic conditions.

And those new opportunities also will be what prudent bootstrapping entrepreneurs who know how to get the most out of every dollar can pursue over the next couple of years.  As Rick Newman points out at US News:

But recessions are times of “creative destruction,” and while the destruction tends to dominate the headlines, new opportunities often sprout as companies seek new ways to grow and those resistant to change drift into obsolescence. Plus, recessions end. And when this one does, we’ll all be ready for a party–on a careful budget.

Conversation on the Morality of Capitalism

The John Templeton Foundation hosts a series of “Big Questions” discussions.  They ask each question to  leading scientists, scholars, and public figures.

The latest question is: “Does the Free Market Erode Moral Character?”

The responses to this question really get to the heart of the current debate about the role that free markets and capitalism played in today’s economic woes.  I would encourage everyone to ponder the responses these folks offer, as we need a more informed debate about what really has been going on and where we go from here.

I will offer my thoughts….

Free markets are morally neutral — neither good nor bad.  What brings morality into free market activities are the actions of people. 

People’s decisions and actions become habits.  First we choose to lie, but eventually if we continue to lie we become a liar.  Virtues are habits, and these habits shape our character over time.

It is time to stop blaming morally neutral systems for what we do and who we become.  Ultimately, we become good or evil through our own actions and decisions that are taken through our own free will. 

It is time to take a long, hard look at our culture; for it is there that we find our shared sense of right and wrong.  We must stop the folly of deferring morality to governmental policy and regulatory control.

(Thanks to my colleague Harry Hollis for passing along the Templeton link).

Credit and Real Estate are Not Top Worries of Entrepreneurs

I just received a copy of a new study from the NFIB Research Foundation looking at the current state of small business credit.

 

First of all, the recession is clearly on the minds of many small business owners.  One-third (34%) of small business owners, defined as small employers having 250 or fewer employees, think the nation’s financial problems have “significantly” affected their business and one-quarter (26%) think it threatens their survival.

 

So what is their short term worry?  Is it access to credit or the real estate crisis as those in Washington seem to be fixated on right now?  Nope.  Here are their immediate worries in order of importance:

 

  • 45% responded that slow or lost sales
  • 23% the unpredictability of business conditions
  •  9% falling real estate values
  •  9% an inability to obtain credit.

Since the beginning of early September, 30% of small employers applied for credit in one form or another, at least half of which applied more than one time (after all, persistence is one of our virtues).  Of those 70% who did not apply, 12% of them (8% of the population) did not apply because they thought they could not get credit they wanted.

 

Of those who went after credit since September, 41% obtained all the credit they wanted, while 8 percent obtained most of it. We are consistently told that nobody can get credit, but half of small business owners who tried got all or most of what they asked for!  In addition, 14% got some of what they asked for.  That makes it two-thirds of those who tried got at least some credit.

 

As one would expect, the ability to obtain credit appears statistically related to financial strength, as measured by greater sales growth in the last two years, fewer mortgages taken out to finance other business activity, fewer upside-down properties, as well as the owner’s positive evaluation of firm performance against the competition, and firm maturity, more specifically, years of operation.

 

Discouraged borrowers, that is, owners who do not attempt to borrow for fear of rejection, are statistically related to what appears to be weak balance sheets.  Specifically, falling real sales over the last two years, ownership of more upside-down properties, lesser use of real estate for collateral, more mortgages taken out to finance other business activity, and the owner’s negative evaluation of firm performance against the competition.

 

Financial institutions have changed the terms or conditions of a line of credit loan, line or credit card for 18 percent of small employers. The changes include a lower limit on a credit card or higher interest on a line of credit, though not all changes, particularly with respect to lines, were adverse.

 

Trade credit (borrowing from suppliers) is growing more difficult to procure. Of the 80 percent who use trade credit, 30% think it has been getting tighter since early September, 14% a lot tighter, while 46% see no change.

 

Small business owners are heavily invested in real estate. A whopping 96% own their personal residence, 49% own all or part of the building and/or land on which their business sits (excluding the one-quarter who operate primarily from the home), and 41% own investment real estate, excluding their residence and business.

 

Real estate, particularly home mortgages, is frequently used to finance or collateralize other business assets. 76% percent have at least one mortgage on the real estate they own with 13% having three or more mortgages.  22% have taken out at least one mortgage to finance business activities. 16% use real estate to collateralize other business assets, including 10 percent who use their homes as collateral. 9% own at least one currently upside-down property.

Welcome to the Club

I have had a lot of questions about the future of entrepreneurship education in light of the current economic hard times.  After all, aren’t people going to be nervous about launching a new business right now? 

My experience has been that we will continue to see a brisk business as young people see few prospects in the traditional corporate career path. 

In fact, even experienced business professionals are also seeing entrepreneurship as the best option for them in a bleak job market.

From MarketWatch:

Business ownership is an ideal way to parlay proven business skills into a road of self-sufficiency. With economic indicators pointing to a lengthy recession, continued corporate downsizing, and growing unemployment, the New Career Economy is today’s reality. In good economic times and bad, the small business owner has been and will continue to be the backbone of our economy. And historically, when there is trouble in the corporate sector, it tends to serve as a launching pad for would-be entrepreneurs.

So to all of you new entrepreneurs out there — welcome to the club!  I know many “accidental” entrepreneurs who started their ventures due to losing their jobs during previous recessions who have never thought of going back to a corporate career. You may not have intended to become one of us, but we are delighted to have you with us.  We are here to help! 

Recession Update from Main Street

I have been waiting with some angst for the November NFIB survey of small business owners.  The results were released this morning.  Overall, these entrepreneurs are not optimistic about the near future, as indicated by the Index of Small Business Optimism which recorded the fourth lowest reading in the 35-year history of the survey. 

So what do the specific items tell us? 

While this is a significant recession, at this point it does not appear to be as bad as the two other major downturns of the past half century.

Employment

 

The reduction in work forces in these small businesses seems to have taken a pause.  The decline in average employment per firm dropped slightly in November, but was not nearly as bad as September and October.  43% of those surveyed hired or tried to hire. This seems remarkably high when compared to the corporate sector, where the news is about hiring freezes and layoffs.  Interestingly, even with the increase in overall unemployment in the US, finding the right people is still a problem.  72% of those trying to hire reported few or no qualified applicants for the job openings they were trying to fill. 

The outlook for employment in small business suggests that we have not hit bottom in this recession.  Over the next three months, only 6% plan to create new jobs, and 17% plan workforce reductions.  This yields a seasonally adjusted net-negative 4% of owners planning to create new jobs, one of the lowest readings in survey history. 

While this is not good news, these findings are not as low as occurred in the 1974-75 or the 1980-82 recession periods. 

Capital Spending

The frequency of reported capital outlays over the past six months rose two points to 56% of all firms, still at recession levels, but still not as bad as we saw in the 1974-1975 downturn. These entrepreneurs are spending a little more on new equipment and new fixtures and furniture.  They are spending a little less on new automobiles.   

Overall, spending is weak, but the frequency of outlays has improved for the last two months and there is a slight increase in planned capital spending over the next few months.

Inventories and Sales

Small business owners continued to reduce inventory levels to adjust to slower sales. 

Earnings  

The net percent of owners reporting higher profits deteriorated further in November.  Seasonally adjusted, those reporting declining earnings trends outnumbered those with gains by 38% percentage points

Profitability is the second worst showing in 35 years of survey history.

Inflation

Nothing tends to kill inflation like a recession.  Price pressures vanished in November.  However, many of the structural causes of inflation are still present, so we need to keep an eye on inflation as the economy rebounds.

Credit

As the economy weakens, loan demand from small business owners continues to decline. 

My Take

While this is a bad recession, for entrepreneurs there is no indication that it is any worse than the last two deep recessions over the past fifty years.  We survived these tough times and will survive this one.

Small business owners are approaching these tough times with a prudent hand: 

·          They are focusing on cash.

·          They are reducing debt.

·          They are tightening inventory.

·          They are being cautious about their overhead expenses.

While business failure will increase, the entrepreneurial spirit is still alive and well.  Our entrepreneurial core should keep us from falling into a deeper recession.  New venture formation will help lead us to the recovery that we can expect by early 2010.

Bootstrapping Resource

My new textbook titled Bootstrapping is now available for pre-orders.  What started out as a single chapter in our book Entrepreneurial Financial Management (second edition of this textbook is due out this spring), grew into a full book that is part of the new entrepreneurship series from Pearson/Prentice-Hall.

 

bootstrapping.jpg

 

The contents:

PART I THE ART OF BOOTSTRAPPING

Chapter 1 Introduction to Bootstrapping

Chapter 2 The Essentials of Bootstrapping

 

PART II BOOTSTRAPPING TECHNIQUES

Chapter 3 Bootstrapping Key Fixed Costs: Overhead and Capital Purchases

Chapter 4 Staffing and Human Resource Bootstrapping

Chapter 5 Bootstrapping Through Efficient Processes

Chapter 6 Bootstrap Marketing: The Start-Up Venture

Chapter 7 Bootstrap Marketing: The Growing Venture5

 

PART III MANAGING A BOOTSTRAPPED BUSINESS

Chapter 8 Start-Up Financing and Day-to-Day Cash Flow Management in a Bootstrapped Business

Chapter 9 Creating and Sustaining a Bootstrap Culture

 

Here is a blurb from the publisher:

 

With a focus on practical techniques, entrepreneurs learn how to stretch resources and thrive on lean budgets. The text focuses on bootstrapping techniques for a variety of ventures-from small, family-owned businesses to high-growth upstarts.  While this book treats the subject of securing initial financing for the start-up venture, it also fully explores how entrepreneurs manage and sustain the business as it grows.